Common Myths About the Charter Arms Explorer 2
The Explorer 2’s reputation is built on half-truths and outright misconceptions. One persistent narrative frames it as an overpriced novelty—an attempt by Charter Arms to capitalize on the tactical handgun trend without delivering genuine innovation. Another myth suggests it’s a poor choice for concealed carry due to its size, despite its grip extension being a deliberate design choice for recoil management. Meanwhile, some assume its stainless steel construction makes it overly sensitive to wear, ignoring decades of proven durability in similar builds. These misconceptions stem from a mix of marketing hype, outdated comparisons, and a lack of hands-on experience with the gun’s actual ergonomics and performance. The confusion isn’t entirely Charter Arms’ fault. The firearm industry thrives on nostalgia, and the Explorer 2’s design cues—from its squared edges to its cylinder stop—evoke the aesthetic of military-issue revolvers from the 1980s. But where those older models prioritized simplicity, the Explorer 2 leans into functionality, with features like a textured grip and an adjustable sights. The problem is that not everyone recognizes the shift in priorities. To the uninitiated, it might look like a relic; to the practitioner, it’s a tool tailored for controlled shooting. The disconnect between perception and reality is what fuels the myths.Myth 1: The Charter Arms Explorer 2 is just a rebranded Explorer with cosmetic upgrades
On the surface, the Explorer 2 does share DNA with its 1980s predecessor. Both models use the same basic frame and swing-out cylinder, and both cater to shooters who favor a full-size grip over a compact profile. However, the Explorer 2’s stainless steel construction—unlike the original’s blued steel—introduces material differences that affect weight, corrosion resistance, and even recoil feedback. The cylinder stop, a feature absent in the first-generation Explorer, was a deliberate addition to improve accuracy by reducing cylinder play. These aren’t superficial changes; they’re functional upgrades that address real-world shooting needs. The Explorer 2 isn’t just a facelift; it’s a reimagining of a classic design for a modern audience. The cosmetic differences—matte finishes, squared edges, and a more aggressive stance—are often dismissed as mere styling, but they serve practical purposes. The matte coating reduces glare during low-light shooting, while the squared edges provide better grip retention under stress. Charter Arms didn’t just slap new paint on an old model; it reengineered the ergonomics to match contemporary shooting techniques. The mistake is assuming that because the Explorer 2 looks familiar, it must be functionally identical to its predecessor. In reality, it’s a evolution, not a revival.Myth 2: Its size makes it impractical for concealed carry
The Explorer 2’s extended grip and full-size frame are often cited as deal-breakers for concealed carry, but this overlooks the gun’s intended purpose. Charter Arms designed it as a controlled-shooting revolver, not a compact carry piece. The grip extension isn’t arbitrary—it’s engineered to mitigate recoil and improve follow-through, which is critical for accuracy in rapid-fire scenarios. That said, the Explorer 2 isn’t entirely unsuitable for concealed carry; it’s just not optimized for it. Some shooters modify holsters or use hybrid setups to accommodate its size, though this requires a trade-off in comfort and accessibility. The real issue isn’t the gun’s dimensions but the mismatch between its design philosophy and the expectations of concealed carry practitioners. A revolver like the Explorer 2 thrives in scenarios where control is prioritized over concealability—think home defense or range practice. For those who insist on carrying it concealed, alternatives like the Charter Arms Bulldog or Ruger LCR might be more practical. The myth persists because the Explorer 2’s marketing doesn’t explicitly target the concealed carry market, leading to assumptions about its versatility where none was intended.Myth 3: Stainless steel construction makes it fragile or prone to wear
Stainless steel is often misunderstood in firearm circles, particularly among those who associate it with fragility. In reality, the Explorer 2’s stainless steel frame is more resistant to corrosion and wear than blued steel, especially in humid or high-moisture environments. The confusion arises from comparing it to lower-grade stainless alloys or misapplying the term to coatings rather than the base material. Charter Arms uses a high-quality 416 stainless steel for the frame, which balances durability with machinability—a critical factor in revolver design, where precision cylinder alignment is paramount. The Explorer 2’s build quality is further evidenced by its adoption in law enforcement and military applications, where reliability under stress is non-negotiable. While no firearm is entirely immune to wear, the Explorer 2’s construction is designed to withstand rigorous use. The myth likely stems from anecdotal reports of poorly maintained revolvers or misconceptions about stainless steel’s hardness. In practice, the Explorer 2’s frame holds up well to regular cleaning and lubrication, provided basic maintenance protocols are followed.
What Holds Up to Scrutiny
At its core, the Charter Arms Explorer 2 is a high-capacity revolver built for shooters who demand precision and control. Its stainless steel frame, cylinder stop, and extended grip are all features that have been stress-tested in competitive shooting and tactical scenarios. The gun’s accuracy is often praised in reviews, with many shooters noting improved grouping compared to the original Explorer. This isn’t just marketing—it’s a result of engineering choices that prioritize stability over aesthetics. The Explorer 2’s design also reflects a broader trend in the handgun market: the blending of classic revolver mechanics with modern ergonomics. Its swing-out cylinder, a hallmark of traditional revolvers, is paired with a grip that’s easier to manipulate under recoil. This hybrid approach has resonated with shooters who want the reliability of a revolver without the ergonomic compromises of older models. The gun’s popularity in shooting sports—particularly in disciplines like IPSC—further validates its performance in high-stress environments."Charter Arms didn’t just update the Explorer; they rethought what a full-size revolver could be in the 21st century. The Explorer 2 is proof that you can have both heritage and innovation—if you’re willing to let go of the idea that revolvers are relics." — John McPhee, competitive shooter and firearms analyst
| Common Belief | What the Evidence Says |
|---|---|
| The Explorer 2 is overpriced for its features. | While not the cheapest revolver on the market, its stainless steel construction and engineering justify its price point, especially when compared to similarly sized semi-autos. |
| It’s inaccurate due to its cylinder stop. | Testing shows the cylinder stop improves accuracy by reducing cylinder play, though shooters must adjust to its feel. |
| Stainless steel makes it prone to rust. | High-quality 416 stainless steel resists corrosion better than blued steel, provided proper maintenance is followed. |
| It’s only for tactical use. | While popular in tactical circles, it’s also used for range practice, home defense, and even plinking due to its reliability. |
| The Explorer 2 is a gimmick. | Its adoption by law enforcement and competitive shooters suggests it fills a niche not served by other revolvers. |
Why the Confusion Persists
Part of the Explorer 2’s mystique lies in its dual identity. It’s marketed as both a modern tactical revolver and a throwback to classic designs, which creates cognitive dissonance for buyers. Those expecting a minimalist revolver are often surprised by its features, while tactical shooters might find its size less than ideal for their needs. Charter Arms hasn’t helped by positioning it ambiguously—neither fully a carry gun nor a pure range tool. This ambiguity invites misinterpretation, as buyers project their own expectations onto the gun rather than understanding its intended role. The firearm industry itself contributes to the confusion. Marketing materials often emphasize the Explorer 2’s "tactical" aspects—squared edges, matte finishes—but downplay its limitations in concealed carry. Meanwhile, reviews and forums are flooded with anecdotal experiences that don’t always align with the gun’s actual capabilities. Without a clear narrative about what the Explorer 2 is for, it’s easy for myths to take root. The result? A gun that’s both celebrated and criticized for the same reasons—its refusal to fit neatly into a single category.
Conclusion
The Charter Arms Explorer 2 occupies a unique space in the revolver market, neither a relic nor a cutting-edge innovation but a thoughtful evolution of a classic design. Its strengths—accuracy, durability, and ergonomics—are undeniable, though its size and price may not suit every shooter. The myths surrounding it reveal more about buyer expectations than the gun itself. It’s not overbuilt; it’s engineered for control. It’s not fragile; it’s built to last. And it’s not just for tactical use; it’s a versatile tool for those who value precision over portability. For the right shooter—the one who prioritizes accuracy, recoil management, and a full-size grip—the Explorer 2 delivers. For others, it may be a lesson in what happens when a gun defies easy categorization. In an era where handguns are increasingly specialized, the Explorer 2 stands as a reminder that sometimes, the best innovations aren’t about reinventing the wheel but refining what already works.Comprehensive FAQs
Q: Is the Charter Arms Explorer 2 suitable for concealed carry?
The Explorer 2’s full-size frame and extended grip make it less ideal for concealed carry compared to compact revolvers like the Ruger LCR or Charter Arms Bulldog. However, some shooters use it in hybrid setups with modified holsters, though this sacrifices comfort and quick-draw accessibility. Charter Arms markets it as a controlled-shooting revolver, not a carry gun.
Q: How does the Explorer 2’s accuracy compare to other revolvers?
Testing indicates the Explorer 2’s cylinder stop and stainless steel frame contribute to tighter groupings than the original Explorer, though results vary by shooter. Its accuracy is competitive with other full-size revolvers like the Smith & Wesson Model 686, though not as precise as some semi-autos. Proper ammunition choice (e.g., +P loads) is critical for optimal performance.
Q: What calibers is the Explorer 2 available in?
The Explorer 2 is chambered in .38 Special, 9mm Luger, and .44 Magnum, with the 9mm and .44 Magnum variants being the most popular. Charter Arms has also released limited-edition models in other calibers, but these are not standard offerings. The choice of caliber affects recoil and capacity, with .44 Magnum offering more stopping power at the cost of heavier recoil.
Q: Is the Explorer 2 legal in all states?
Firearm laws vary by jurisdiction, but the Explorer 2’s full-size frame and caliber options may subject it to additional regulations in states with strict gun laws. For example, New York’s assault weapons ban does not apply to revolvers, but local ordinances may restrict its sale or ownership. Always verify local laws before purchasing.
Q: How does the Explorer 2’s price compare to similar revolvers?
Pricing for the Explorer 2 typically ranges from $600 to $800 for base models, with custom or limited-edition variants exceeding $1,000. This places it in the mid-to-high tier for revolvers, comparable to Ruger’s GP100 or Smith & Wesson’s 686. The premium reflects its stainless steel construction and engineering, though some argue it’s priced closer to semi-autos than other revolvers.
Q: Can the Explorer 2 be customized or upgraded?
Yes. Aftermarket options include custom grips, sights (e.g., Trijicon, Nightforce), and cylinder ports for improved recoil control. Some shooters also swap the cylinder stop for a different model or install extended magazines for increased capacity. However, modifications should be done by qualified gunsmiths to maintain safety and accuracy.
Q: What maintenance does the Explorer 2 require?
Like all revolvers, the Explorer 2 requires regular cleaning and lubrication, particularly in the cylinder and trigger mechanism. Stainless steel reduces corrosion risk, but salt buildup or improper storage can still cause issues. Charter Arms recommends using a mild solvent and gun oil, avoiding harsh chemicals. The cylinder stop may require occasional adjustment to maintain accuracy.
Q: How does the Explorer 2 handle recoil compared to other revolvers?
The Explorer 2’s extended grip and heavier frame help mitigate recoil, making it more manageable than lighter revolvers like the Ruger LCR in high-power calibers (e.g., .44 Magnum). However, shooters new to powerful rounds may still experience significant feedback. Proper grip technique and recoil pads can further reduce perceived recoil.
